Schrodinger's hostage deal: What exactly is Israel conceding?

With reports of a possible partial hostage deal being reached between Israel and Hamas, at least two reports have come out claiming to contain its unconfirmed or unfinalized details.

One comes from Channel 12 News:

"Israel agreed to give a guarantee to Hamas that if there is no agreement on the terms for ending the war during the temporary ceasefire, discussions will continue beyond the 60 days.

"President Trump will personally guarantee this to Hamas and will even declare it publicly.

"The proposal includes the release of 10 living hostages (8 on the first day, 2 on the 50th day of the ceasefire), and three more phases of releasing deceased hostages (18 in total over 60 days).

"In the next stage, if terms for ending the war are agreed upon, the remaining hostages will be released (10 living and 12 deceased).

"The release keys will be similar to those of the previous deal. The names of the terrorists that Hamas will demand will be difficult to accept and will include those that Israel has refused to release so far.

"On the Israeli side - professional teams composed of intelligence and medical personnel will determine the list of names that Israel will pass to Hamas - and then negotiations between the sides on the names will begin. It's likely that Israel will ask to start with releasing the sickest and most wounded.

"Still under discussion: Israel demands to keep the current aid mechanism, namely through the American company. Hamas demands to dismantle the arrangement and return to the previous model where 400-600 trucks entered the Strip daily with humanitarian aid, many of which fell into its hands."

Meanwhile, the New York Times claims these are the, as yet, unfinalized details:

"According to an Israeli security source and a Palestinian source close to Hamas, the deal will include the release of the 10 remaining living hostages and the return of 18 bodies still held by Hamas in Gaza in exchange for Palestinian prisoners.

"The release of the hostages and return of the bodies will be carried out gradually, at five different times over a period of 60 days. This is a change from what was described in an American proposal from May, according to which all hostages were supposed to be released by the seventh day of the ceasefire.

"Hamas will also refrain from holding televised hostage handover ceremonies, like those it conducted when releasing hostages during the two-month ceasefire that began in January.

"The Israeli source confirmed to the newspaper that the current proposal is designed to assure Hamas that the temporary ceasefire will include within it paving the way for an end to the war."