Luxury Bags, Tiny Paychecks: The Dark Side of Pirarucu Fashion
Explore how the endangered pirarucu fish became a luxury fashion commodity, revealing the stark contrast between high-end prices and local fishermen's earnings in the Amazon.
Twitter
From Threatened Species to Luxury Fashion
The pirarucu, one of the largest freshwater fish in the world, was once endangered due to overfishing. Today, its thick skin is transformed into high-end handbags and accessories sold in Brazil and the U.S. Fashion brands and environmental authorities tout this as an example of sustainable use.
Under current regulations, only a portion of adult pirarucu may be captured, ensuring population conservation while providing income for indigenous and riverine communities. Brands like Osklen emphasize the socio-environmental benefits, while U.S. label Piper & Skye markets its products as a combination of luxury and sustainability.
Profits Don’t Reach the Fishermen
Despite the focus on sustainability, most of the profits from luxury products rarely reach the communities that safeguard the fish. Pedro Canízio, vice-president of the Federation of Pirarucu Managers in Mamirauá, reports that fishers earn only around R$11 per kilo of pirarucu, far below the cost of luxury items made from the skin.
Experts note that this imbalance is common in Amazonian supply chains. While sustainable management has helped the species recover, economic benefits remain concentrated in industrial and export markets.
Local Initiatives and Challenges
Some communities are trying to retain more value locally. The Gosto da Amazônia brand, run by the Association of Rural Producers of Carauari (Asproc), sells pirarucu meat and hopes to eventually process the skin. Technical and financial barriers, however, prevent small-scale leather production, leaving most high-value processing to industrial facilities.
Nova Kaeru, a dominant company in the pirarucu leather market, supplies luxury brands such as Armani, Dolce & Gabbana, and Givenchy. Its technological innovations allow for large, continuous leather surfaces, making it a leader in this niche market.
Environmental Oversight Remains Fragile
Illegal fishing remains a persistent problem. Since 2000, more than 1,100 environmental fines have been issued in Amazonas alone, mostly for unauthorized capture or transport of pirarucu. Authorities acknowledge limited capacity to monitor the entire supply chain, making it difficult to ensure that luxury products come exclusively from legally managed fish.
A Socio-Environmental Success With Limits
Despite these challenges, experts agree that pirarucu management is one of the most socially and environmentally beneficial economic activities in the Amazon. However, to remain effective, it must ensure that the communities protecting the fish also receive a fair share of the profits.