Southern Commander Accuses Air Force Chief of “Detachment” Amid Gaza Dispute

A heated confrontation erupted last Thursday in a high-level military meeting at the IDF’s Kirya headquarters in Tel Aviv, revealing deep divisions between senior Israeli commanders over the military’s conduct in Gaza.

During a situation assessment conducted via video from Southern Command headquarters in Be’er Sheva, Southern Command Chief Maj. Gen. Yaniv Asor challenged Air Force Commander Maj. Gen. Tomer Bar over his repeated interference in decisions related to airstrikes in the Gaza Strip.

According to several witnesses present at the meeting, attended by over 20 generals and senior officers, the discussion quickly escalated into a shouting match.

At the heart of the dispute is a growing rift between Southern Command and the Israeli Air Force over Israel’s increasingly aggressive fire policy in Gaza. Gen. Asor accused Bar of obstructing airstrike decisions, while Bar countered that many of the strike requests lacked operational professionalism.

“You in Tel Aviv are disconnected from the field,” Gen. Asor reportedly shouted, prompting the IDF Chief of Staff to intervene, warning that such remarks were “unacceptable.”

Background: Frustration Over Gaza Ground Operation

The rare confrontation follows mounting frustration within the IDF over the results of Operation “Gideon’s Chariots,” a large-scale military campaign in Gaza aimed at pressuring Hamas into a hostage deal. Despite initial success in eliminating dozens of Hamas commanders in a surprise nighttime strike, the campaign failed to achieve its stated goal of forcing a breakthrough in negotiations.

Moreover, the operation has drawn intense international criticism due to widespread civilian casualties, including women and children. Multiple reports have accused Southern Command of adopting overly broad rules of engagement, targeting low-level Hamas operatives even when the risk of collateral damage was high.

“This isn’t about providing close air support to troops under fire,” said one senior defense official. “Southern Command pushed the fire policy to the limit, changing definitions of acceptable collateral damage in ways that created more harm than benefit.”

Internal Criticism and Command Tensions

Maj. Gen. Asor, who took over following the resignation of his predecessor after the October 7 failures, has reportedly clashed with other military branches in recent months. According to IDF sources, his confrontational style has led many officers to limit professional interaction with him.

There is also growing criticism within the IDF regarding the ground campaign’s lack of progress. Despite significant troop deployments and heavy combat, the operation has not brought Hamas closer to defeat or led to the release of hostages. In a letter published recently by Ynet, a reserve company commander voiced what many field officers have echoed: “There is no real maneuver. The troops are exhausted. The enemy senses weakness and attacks.”

Tensions were exacerbated by a political directive to limit press access to the battlefield during the campaign, now rebranded from Operation “Shield and Arrow” to “Gideon’s Chariots.”

Looking Ahead

Despite the public fallout, the two generals are now tasked with formulating the IDF’s next operational plan for Gaza, following the breakdown of talks for a hostage deal.

“This kind of confrontation between generals at General Staff level is unprecedented,” said officers who witnessed the exchange. “While disagreements are encouraged, and difficult debates have occurred throughout the war, this one bordered on personal and required the Chief of Staff’s direct intervention.”

The IDF confirmed the events but declined to comment further.