How the World’s Newsrooms Turned a Hamas Commander into a ‘Journalist’
BBC and New York Times echo Hamas-linked network’s claims, while Germany’s Bild calls it what it is — a terrorist disguised as a reporter.
Twitter
The IDF has confirmed the elimination of Anas al-Sharif — a Hamas operative working under the cover of a “journalist” for Al Jazeera in Gaza. The military released extensive intelligence proving his role within Hamas’s military wing, including official personnel rosters, terror training course lists, internal phonebooks, and salary records — all tying him directly to the group’s operations.
According to the IDF, al-Sharif was not merely affiliated with Hamas — he was a cell leader actively involved in planning and coordinating rocket attacks targeting Israeli civilians and military forces. His work at Al Jazeera, the IDF says, served as a convenient cover for his terrorist activities.
Global headlines tell a different story
Despite the hard evidence, several leading international outlets chose to frame the incident as an attack on press freedom. The BBC’s headline read, “Five Al Jazeera Journalists Killed in Israeli Strike”, uncritically amplifying Al Jazeera’s narrative that the strike was a “blatant and premeditated attack on press freedom.” The New York Times similarly echoed the claim that “four journalists were killed,” giving prominent space to statements from the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) accusing Israel of targeting al-Sharif because he had previously cried on air over conditions in Gaza.
Neither outlet led with the documented fact that al-Sharif was a Hamas operative. The IDF’s evidence was mentioned — but buried deep in their coverage.
Who told the truth?
Some media, however, reported the story accurately. The UK’s Telegraph ran the headline, “Israel Kills Al Jazeera Journalist Accused of Leading Hamas Terror Cell”, and cited the IDF’s statement that “a press badge does not grant immunity for terrorism.” Germany’s Bild went further, publishing: “Terrorist Disguised as Journalist Killed in Gaza” and detailing his operational role in Hamas.
The bigger picture
This is not the first time a Hamas operative has been embedded in media organizations in Gaza. Israeli intelligence has repeatedly revealed cases where individuals holding press credentials were directly involved in terrorist activities — from coordinating attacks to serving as lookouts for Hamas cells. In some cases, media gear and press vehicles have been used to transport weapons or fighters.
The IDF has emphasized that while Israel respects the role of legitimate journalists, it will not allow Hamas to use the press as a shield for terrorism. “A press badge does not grant immunity for terrorism,” an IDF spokesperson reiterated.
The stark difference between outlets that reported al-Sharif’s true identity and those that repeated Hamas talking points underscores a wider problem: much of the global narrative on Gaza is shaped by sources with clear political agendas. When newsrooms ignore or downplay documented terror affiliations, they risk turning propaganda into “fact” — and erasing the line between journalism and jihad.